I don’t know about you, but American Idol, for me, is the most wonderful time of the year. At last, I can witness the humilation that Fox will put willing contestants through; I can delight in Simon’s thought-provoking insults; I can continue to wonder what the hell is in Paula’s cup.
The first episode was, in some ways, slightly disappointing. Oh, yes, we saw the really horrible people, and of course only a few of the good ones, but where on earth was all the drama this time?
Apparently, it was in the form of a cold washcloth and a peeled banana. But I’m jumping ahead. Let’s discuss some favorite moments.

OH, OKAY! Yeah, whatever that means. This is doublefunny to me because everybody was asking for his book and cd/dvd last week, which is entitled Hit Man. We ran out of both, so I ordered some more, and now of course nobody wants them. Hopefully he’ll do an appearance on the show and I will be redeemed. Meanwhile, what a bizarre choice of an opener.
So, as we all know, there’s a new judge this season. Part of me thinks it’s because they’re trying to whip all the old viewers into a new frenzy over.. well.. nothing, and the other, more rational part says, “Paula Abdul complained so much about being sexually harrassed by Simon that they figured the only way to get her to shut the hell up was to get another lady on the show.”
Judging by the first night (haha, get it? JUDGING?), Ms. DioGuardi is kinda somewhat sorta doing her job. (If it is to protect Paula. And if that’s all true, I don’t know why we had to be subjected to a clip of them making out. There is nothing wrong with a television makeout every now and again, but it was at least kinda funny when it was Paula and Simon. Now it is just strange. Why must American Idol be automatically turned into Girls Gone Wild just because there are now two females to make that joke possible? I don’t know. I blame the producers.)
Anywho, the judges. Oh, and Ryan, the whipping boy.

Despite the fact that a) Randy appears to be gaining weight again; b) Kara’s makeup is a bit eye-heavy; c) Simon is Simon and therefore all is well with the world; d) Paula is dressed for the prom, and apparently the theme is Puke; and e) poor Ryan was all but forgotten on the first night, the line-up is working fine for now. As my sister and I decided, Kara is like a more outspoken, intelligent Paula. Of course, this means she is also kind of a bitch. But not necessarily in a bad way. It’s tough. When Simon is a jerk, people say, “Oh that Simon! What a jerk!” and it’s okay because he’s male. But if a lady says nasty (but true) things, everybody says, “Damn, she is a bitch.”
From what I have seen of Kara, I think she’s going to do just fine. I am also fairly certain she is going to have knock-down drag-out bitch-slap fest with some girl later in the show, but that’s cool. Pull some hair, pinch hard enough to leave a bruise, and everybody can go home happy.
Now, more on Ryan:

Here is a man who is confident enough in his masculinity that he can wear the clothing of one waiting for the river to rise. In Los Angeles. (That’s why his shirt says “City of Angels”. He is a clever, clever man.) This picture is funny on at least 539874609783475 levels, but I don’t want to talk about any of those just now. I want to ask WHERE WAS HE DURING THE FIRST EPISODE.
Look, maybe my memory is failing me from last season and the one before that, but like.. where were all the stupid, pointless interviews of hopeful wannabe singers in the hallway with twenty thousand American Idol signs plastered all over the walls? Where was Ryan in the tryout room, being ignorant to Simon and hugging every female contestant, far too tightly for television? I don’t know. I think he wandered off somewhere in the canyon for those two days and the producers had to edit together the shots of him that they had. Maybe Ryan is still upset about Brangelina blowing him off at the Golden Globes. Maybe Ryan is working on a plan to end world hunger, or perhaps writing a thesis to get his Master’s Degree in Sun-In Hair Highlights. Whatever the case, I miss you, Ryan Seacrest. I have waited many months to see your idiotic smiling, tanned face. I will slip Nigel or whatever his name is a $20 if he gives you more screentime, okay? Okay.

Okay, Simon, I missed you too.
Without further ado, the contestants — but only the ones I feel like talking about. If you’re looking for another picture of Ryan highfiving that poor blind guy (a classic Ryan moment), go elsewhere. Words cannot even express the ridiculousness of the two-hour build-up Fox put me through, for a mere two minutes of Scott McIntyre singing Billy Joel. I mean, look, I like Billy Joel, but not enough to wait two hours for it. And of course they were going to pass Scott on. He is blind. It would be really awful if they said no to him. More awful than how they already exploited him to death. Besides, Scott can sing; they would’ve passed him regardless of his handicap.. okay, the other contestants. Let’s do that.
First up is Miss Emily, who is very sweet, has a lovely voice, but..

That’s.. a lot. Of make-up, that is. Her face is so shiny and perspiring. Her pores are crying for love and attention. Also, this was in Phoenix, so that probably didn’t help either. Okay, yeah, also, she’s got a lot of other stuff going on there. If she wants to be all tattooed and gauged and this and that and whatever, that’s fine, but good lord, woman. Are you trying really hard, or is that what you really want to look like? You will be old one day, you know. You might regret it. I’m just sayin’. Despite that, she seems like a very nice person and hopefully will not fall into the trap of singing 9,000 Heart songs like everybody else did last season, both during tryouts and the actual show. If Heart actually had 9,000 songs, I think I would be in shock. Regardless, Emily. Nice girl. Glad they passed her. Moving along.

..sigh. This was a mistake from the start. Firstly, this open-shirted lad is named Randy. (I was confused, briefly, during his audition because there were two Randys in the same room and that’s a lot of Randy, if you know what I mean.) Randy, this Randy, is allegedly a “rocker”. He dyes his hair black, wears a lot of black clothing, and enjoys adorning himself with skulls and ah yes, the obligatory “rocker” cross around his neck. Rocker Randy is probably deep down a little pussycat, but in public he prefers to be known as a panther. Grrrrowl. Etc. I am also fairly confident that Rocker Randy has a lot of mental issues, or perhaps the producers are excellent at editing, because he was either like the above screenshot or:

Crying. Crying, crying, crying. Sobbing into his soul patch. (I hope that’s a soul patch; perhaps it is a tumbleweed blowing down his chin, or maybe, more realistically, a shadow.) For a Rocker, Randy sure did a lot of crying. Good thing he wasn’t wearing eyeliner — which, technically, he should have been, as he is a Rocker. But hey, if Simon made this face at me, I’d be crying too.

Crying with delight, laughter, and sure, yes, I will meet you in your trailer after the show. Anyway, I am still a bit confused as to why Rocker Randy was commanded — yes, COMMANDED — to join a band. If you feel that he is a poseur (which he is) and that he can’t really sing (also true) then why on earth do you feel he needs to further subject his poseur, non-talented ass to a group of talented musicians? I don’t get it. I suppose they all meant well, but it isn’t like he was pleased with their advice. He, naturally, cried. Here’s a fellow, however, who did not cry, but took it like a man. A man with a ridiculous head of hair.

Sweetheart, there comes a time in all our lives when we have to say, “Cut the mullet.” Or, in your case, “Cut the afro.” He explained that he is half-Vietnamese and half-Caucasian, and that “no Vietnamese person has hair like his”. Well.. duh. Because it’s awful. Why would anybody, regardless of race, do that to themselves? An afro is one thing; having a family of birds happily nesting in your hair is quite another. Again, seems like a nice boy, but really trying far too hard. And what was WITH his dance moves? Ugh. Ugh, ugh, ugh. At least he didn’t wear a chicken costume or whatever.

Another contestant who seems like a lovely person, but is ruined by the editing process. I forget her name, but she’s a 25 year old bartender waitress whatever from Kentucky. For some reason, I thought of Sookie (Sookee? S-dizzle?) from True Blood. I guess it was the blonde hair and naïveté that did it for me. So, anyway. She came to the auditions without a family, which is a common occurrence as some kids will lie and audition without their parents being none the wiser, but since she was 25 I didn’t think she was going to be too broken up about it. And she wasn’t. But she still decided to “adopt a family” anyway. Above, she is pictured with the only member of her “adopted family”, a small moustached man who I think spoke broken English. He disappeared after that scene and did not reappear later, even after she made it. Well, what kind of a family is that, I ask you? He should have at least been there to pat her on the arm or something. Depressing.

Also depressing, but in a completely different way. I think her name is Katrina. Katerina? Kat.. whatever. Bikini is what we’ll call her, because that’s evidently all she cares to be known for. Any twit that strolls into an American Idol audition in costume — and that’s what what her bikini was, a costume and cry for attention — deserves to be criticized, made fun of, and hopefully told they have no talent. Because the untalented ones are generally the ones wearing the costumes. They have nothing else going for them, and they figure at least they’ll get some screen time. Unfortunately, Lady Bikini got far too much screen time. There wasn’t really anything else going on, so I guess they figured, hey! Why not! Who doesn’t want to see a girl in a bikini!
Well, I don’t. She wasn’t that pretty, for one thing, nor was her body so devastatingly amazing that I felt compelled to agree with her choice of clothing (or lack thereof). And she was a bitch. She can sing — if you’re into whiny, “ooh, look at me, I’m going to drag this note out for a long time and wiggle my arm up and down like a diva I saw on TV once”, dull singing. Sure, then, she can sing. But to be so ignorant to the judges, for the judges to be ignorant right back (Kara baby, I’m lookin’ at you here).. I don’t know. The entire bit left a nasty taste in my mouth. And also in Ryan’s:

Yes, this is Ryan Seacrest having his face sucked off by Lady Bikini, because she decided when she got her “golden ticket” to Hollywood, she was going to “make out with Ryan”. Yup. Mmhm. Wow. Lucky him, huh? I’m so jealous. I long for the days when a young, bikini-clad upstart makes my day with a face-swallowing kiss that smells strongly of Mystic Tan. Mm, mm, mm. Doesn’t matter, really, cause you know she’s going to get knocked out during Hollywood Week. Lady Bikini has no staying power. I predict a mudwrestling jamboree, lots of tears, and her getting bleeped out when talking about Kara in her exit interview. “You haven’t see the last of me!” she’ll cackle, and dissolve into a puddle of tanning solution.

HOLY SHIT ELIJAH WOOD! Hey, what’s up? Getting bored until The Hobbit starts filming? Or has it, already? Or maybe you’re not even in that. Well, cheer up. They’ll give you a bit part, somewhere. Or perhaps a “flash-forward” scene into the future, as your hairy feet clamber up Mount Doom or something. In the meantime, you should probably not audition for American Idol. I know you’re lonely and stuff, but count your blessings and give Sean Astin a call. You’ll feel better, I promise.

What the hell are you laughing at? Oh, wait, it’s you. That creature who laughed at.. everything. She was one of the many 16/17 year olds featured on the show, but thankfully was not passed on, because she couldn’t stop laughing. She laughed at her name, her song choice, her this, her that, her.. whatever. She was so frightening. I’m fairly confident she was under the influence of Pixi Stix, Pop Rocks, and Tang. Did anyone else notice how her hair got bigger and scarier further into the episode? Also, I totally didn’t buy the whole “omg liek I am Kara Diowhosits BIGGEST FAN”.. really? Considering most of us weren’t exactly sure who Kara is, I highly doubt that. Yes, sure, the woman’s written a load of songs and been in studios with famous people, but you’re like 16. You care more about, like, the color pink. And your Gigundo Binder o’ Songs.

Seriously, that thing was huge. And thick. See how excited Ryan was? Nah, just kidding. His caftan shirt delight thing calmed him down.
Anyway, it was no surprise when she was dismissed from the room, sans a golden ticket. But it was apparently surprising to her.

Sorry babe, but you’re 16. Your music is probably nowhere near a cross between Madonna and whoever else you said, and for heaven’s sake, get some hair serum. Afro Boy might try to mate with your hair and the world would probably end.

Ah, Michael Gurr. Another child who suffered from the editing process. And apparently lack of potassium? I am sure in real life he isn’t such a greasy-looking dweeb, but as I sat in my family room watching him I kept thinking, “Conor Oberst?” and then I thought, “Ew, I hate Conor Oberst” and then I further thought, “..wow, I really don’t like Conor Oberst, and this kid really can’t sing”.
Whenever a male has attempted to sing a song sung by a female singer, it has never gone well. I think there was maybe one instance of it almost turning out okay last season, but it was still met with a lot of criticism. And so when he announced he was singing Carrie Underwood, my stomach dropped a little bit.

He isn’t in pain. They haven’t even critiqued him yet. He is “singing”.






That face drop is CLASSIC. I feel terrible, but come ON. Carrie Underwood (who is quite talented, even if I do not care for her type of music or really, much else about her) is not within your vocal range. Frankly, I don’t know what is in your vocal range, but I can safely say not anything sung by a female. You don’t have the same sort of voice. If you could sing soprano or alto or anything like that, well, I’d be worrying a little. Cut your losses, my friend. At least you got a banana.

The fact that they showed his “dramatic” hallway scene in black and white is even funnier than the whole breakdown. I am sure he was indeed very nervous, like most of the other kids are, but to be that upset afterwards is a little silly. It isn’t the end of the world. You’ve still got your senior year and college ahead of you. There are bazillions of people who audition for American Idol, barely any out of that number go to Hollywood Week, and still few from that go on to the actual show. With odds like that, you can’t have really expected to make it. Even some of the halfway decent people are told no. Ah well. Michael Gurr will be an internet celebrity and hopefully that’s good enough for now.
To close, possibly my favorite auditionee of all time.

Sir, the Shakespeare auditions are room 211. This is American Idol. No, no, save that love sonnet. I don’t want to hear if you’re going to be this or not be that — wherefore art thou? In the wrong room. There’s a good chap. Go on, now. There’s a razor waiting for your beard, and scissors for your ponytail.
He was my Midwinter’s Night Dream. Wink, wink.
Anyway, I have yet to see the second evening of auditions, but rest assured that when I do, it will be discussed. At length. With pictures. Also, Simon. Ah, Simon. Remember that one time he likened an auditionee’s singing to that of a horror film? Me too. Gimme a pound, dawg!